Back to the encounters
CASE FILE / 058 — 1972

The Shooting at Braeside Farm

In 1972 a farmhand on Braeside farm saw a ball of fire hanging over the bush. By noon the farmer and two policemen had fired some fifteen rifle shots at a dark, shiny object that shied from voices, changed color when hit, and crashed away through the undergrowth leaving nine prints in the clay. A police general said he knew of no law against shooting at invaders from outer space.

Wide color photograph of green grassland dotted with low thorn trees behind a sagging wire fence on wooden posts, with a two-lane tarred road running off into the distance at right, under a heavy, layered blue-grey storm sky with bands of low cloud over the far hills.
1972
Thornveld and fenced farmland near Middledrift, about 30 kilometers east of Fort Beaufort, under a storm sky in 2008. Photo: Lysippos, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

A fire near the krans

Monday, June 26, 1972, was a clear, mild winter morning in the Eastern Cape. On Braeside, a farm about 15 kilometers outside Fort Beaufort, a farmhand later named in the records as Boer de Klerk was out in the veld near the farm reservoir when he saw smoke near the krans, the rocky outcrop, and then a ball of fire hanging at the height of the trees. The farm belonged to Bennie Smit, whom the papers would call a down-to-earth plumber from East London, a crack shot and, years later, an acclaimed hunter. By Smit’s own account, published in the Sunday Times the following Sunday, “At 9am one of my labourers reported that he had seen smoke near the krans and then a big ball of fire.” Smit went to look. “Sure enough, there was a fiery ball, hovering at treetop height. It was about 2½ feet across with flames shooting out. My man shouted, and it moved sideways for about 300 yards and disappeared behind a big bush.” When it came back it was changing color: “When I first looked it was a big, red ball, but now it was green and it suddenly changed to a yellowish-white.” Nine nights earlier, at midnight, a neighbor about a kilometer away, Fraser Moss, had heard a drumming noise in the sky and seen nothing.

Sources: The 1972 South African ‘Flap’The South African FlapStop Press: South Africa: Farmer and Police fire shots at UFONotice to unidentified flying objects: try to avoid South AfricaSouth African police fire at UFO

The .303

“I was shocked and felt this thing could be dangerous,” Smit said. “I hurried back to the house to fetch my .303 rifle and phoned the police. I went back to the spot and fired several shots. I am sure my eighth shot hit it, as I heard a thud. It moved up and down and disappeared behind the trees again.” Twenty-five years later he told it with more fear in it. He had gone into the bush thinking his labourers had gone to the wrong camp and lit a fire there to keep warm, and found them cowering in a shed, muttering about something in the bush. “When I saw it, my whole body got goosebumps. I sprinted home and got my .303 and told someone to call the police. I knew I was safe if I had my gun.” In the version printed by the Danish newspaper Aalborg Stiftstidende, Smit explained why he had not fired sooner: at first his men were in the line of fire, and when the object dipped he fired at its star.

Sources: The 1972 South African ‘Flap’The South African FlapFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972UFO fik en varm velkomst i Sydafrika

Two policemen and a joke about Martians

At the police station in Fort Beaufort, a garrison town of the old frontier wars at the meeting of the Kat and Brak rivers, the call reached Sergeant P. C. Kitching. He had eight years in the South African Police. He persuaded his station commander, Warrant Officer P. R. van Rensburg, to come with him; Van Rensburg later said Kitching had burst into his office three times before he gave in. They reached Braeside at about nine or ten, depending on the account, and found Smit coming out of the thick bush, sweating. “Bennie’s first words were that he thought the UFO could be from outer space,” Van Rensburg recalled. “I then joked that the Martians had come to steal his sheep. Then I saw it coming out of the trees and I did not want to believe my eyes.” Kitching, in an account he wrote for a Canadian investigator decades later, remembered the first quiet minutes differently. Seven of them, four labourers, two policemen and the farmer, stood looking at a hill about 150 meters off, and saw nothing, and were skeptical. Then “I saw an object which emerged from the thick bush and vegetation at the foot of the hill and hovered just above the vegetation. It moved slowly to our right and again disappeared behind the thick bush… I had the feeling that we were being watched.”

Color photograph of a squat, round tower of weathered honey-brown sandstone blocks with a single small window, a projecting stone box near the top at left, and a rust-red external staircase climbing to a doorway, standing above a lawn and a rockery of aloes and agaves under a blue sky with white clouds.
The Martello tower at Fort Beaufort, completed in 1846 for the frontier wars and said to be the only one built far from the sea, photographed in 1988. Sergeant Kitching and Warrant Officer van Rensburg set out for Braeside from the police station in this old garrison town. Photo: Janek Szymanowski, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Janek Szymanowski

Sources: Stop Press: South Africa: Farmer and Police fire shots at UFOFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972South African police fire at UFOFort Beaufort

A black, shiny thing that shied away

What the policemen saw was not a ball of fire. “After Mr. Smit and Sgt. Kitching had fired a couple of shots in the direction of the ball of fire,” Van Rensburg told the press, “we saw a round, black, shiny object about 2½ feet in diameter emerge from behind a tree. It slowly disappeared from sight and then reappeared. Shots fired had no effect, but when anyone approached it shied away behind the bushes.” Kitching, speaking to Flying Saucer Review’s correspondent Ivan Clark that year, described an egg-shaped thing about three meters long, floating lengthwise and half hidden behind vegetation, blue-black like the metal of a revolver, which began to glow red all over while they watched; then a bright, star-like light appeared on one side of it, blinking at intervals. Smit, in the wire story, saw “a star-like protuberance at the right end of the oval-shaped object, something that seemed to grow in size as the white light it emitted grew in intensity.” The Natal Daily News, briefed by the police in Grahamstown, settled on “an oval object, gun-metal in colour, about 3/4 m across. It glowed and frequently changed colour from green to yellow to white.” Whatever it was, it seemed to listen. When the labourers shouted from the bush, it sank out of sight; when people came near, it moved off. Smit’s men tried to drive it out of the bush, one report said, much as they would herd livestock.

Sources: The 1972 South African ‘Flap’The South African FlapLanding ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972Notice to unidentified flying objects: try to avoid South AfricaMysterious VisitorsWorld Atlas of UFOs

Fifteen shots

It was Kitching who had taken Smit’s rifle. “I fired three shots at it, hitting with each shot,” he wrote. “During firing at it, I saw a sharp bright light, flickering on the right of the craft, just above it.” The policemen told Clark in 1972 that of the fifteen rounds the seventh struck, with what Kitching called a dull sound, and that the object rolled from side to side and then ran through red, green and yellow. The first newspaper accounts counted at least fifteen .303 rounds, some fired by Smit from as close as seven meters; a New Zealand wire story had the police firing pistols from eight yards. By a later account, after Smit fired at the star-like light, the object stopped changing color and stayed a dark gun-metal body. None of it seemed to do any harm. Smit said that it moved slowly while all fifteen shots were fired and that its course was unaffected. Years later he said the bullets had bounced off. Van Rensburg would one day be asked why he had ordered his sergeant to shoot. In a quotation collected by the American researcher Bob Gribble, he replied only: “The matter is closed.”

Sources: South African police fire at UFOLanding ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972Mysterious VisitorsNotice to unidentified flying objects: try to avoid South AfricaLooking BackThe 1972 South African ‘Flap’Farmer shoots at UFO in 1972

The handkerchief on a stick

Then Smit went in after it; in the policemen’s version told to Clark, this walk came first, and the volley only after it failed. The men cut a reed, or a stick, and tied a white handkerchief to the end so that the policemen on the rise could follow him through the bush and shout directions. “I was just as scared as the others and was relieved when Bennie decided to go into the bush with the stick,” Van Rensburg said in 1997. Smit found it. “Suddenly I saw it about 20 yards away, now greyish-white, I fired two quick shots, but with a loud whirring noise it veered off over treetops, cutting a path through the foliage. It disappeared quickly from sight.” In the Sunday Tribune he added a detail that later writers kept returning to: “When it disappeared in the dense bush we could hear it crashing through the undergrowth, but when we followed we could see no sign of its passage.” To APRO’s South African representative, Frank Morton, he insisted that the trees and bushes had parted for the thing as it went, and that no blast of air had done it. It left nothing burned. By Kitching’s account, it turned upright before it veered off. The watchers on the rise never saw it leave. Kitching never understood, he wrote, how the object could “have vanished into thin air.” Smit’s dog, his constant companion, was missing the whole time.

Color photograph of a single stone arch bridge with a white concrete post-and-rail parapet spanning a gully choked with dense green bush, tall grasses and a yellow-flowering shrub in the foreground, with a windmill and a house roof among trees beyond under a pale cloudy sky.
The Victoria Bridge, built in the 1840s to carry the military road over the Kat River at Fort Beaufort, in 2012. The riverine bush of the district is the kind of cover the object slipped in and out of on Braeside. Photo: Lugerda, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Lugerda

Sources: Farmer shoots at UFO in 1972The 1972 South African ‘Flap’The South African FlapSouth African police fire at UFO

Nine marks in the clay

Where the object had hung, Smit found a circle of what the wire story called fist-like imprints in the sand. On Wednesday, Brigadier A. Vosloo, the police divisional commissioner for the Eastern Cape, led a squad out from Grahamstown at dawn; twelve policemen combed about four square kilometers, and a flying instructor, Sandy Matthew, and an amateur photographer, Brian Lawrie, took some forty aerial photographs looking for scorched bush. The police photographed the marks and took plaster casts. An order to release the photographs to the press was later countermanded. Clark counted three sets of three prints in damp clay, each about 6½ centimeters across and twisted slightly clockwise, as though a leg had been screwed into the ground; Van Rensburg dug one out to show him. C. S. Kingsley, a geology lecturer at Fort Hare University who had been a government geologist on the 1967 Antarctic expedition, examined samples and called the prints “definitely not animal or human.” Fine parallel streaks in them suggested “metal rather than something soft and fleshy.” The Pretoria News described the prints as round, about ten millimeters deep at the center and shallower toward the rim, “as if a spherical object had made them.” Van Rensburg never forgot the depth. “There were nine marks in the clay and the three-legged craft looked like it had landed there three times,” he said in 1997. “The marks were very deep — at least twice the depth my heeled shoes made. I weighed 90kg and hardly made a mark.”

Sources: Stop Press: South Africa: Farmer and Police fire shots at UFOMysterious VisitorsThe 1972 South African ‘Flap’Landing ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972The South African FlapFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972

The train crash and the fruit bottles

The samples had a strange journey. A parcel of plaster casts went north by train to the laboratories of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) in Pretoria on June 29, and never arrived: The Star reported that it was lost in a train crash at Norvalspont. Van Rensburg later said he had offered to carry the samples himself and was told to send them by train. A second parcel did reach Pretoria, two samples packed in canned-fruit bottles, one of ordinary soil and one from the landing site. “The soil samples were tested in a number of ways,” a CSIR spokesman said, “but no significant differences could be found between them.” The Pretoria News reported that if anything had touched the ground, it had done so without changing the soil, and that there was nothing to indicate a rocket.

Sources: The 1972 South African ‘Flap’Farmer shoots at UFO in 1972South African Mini-Wave, 1972—Part 2

Is it legal to shoot a flying saucer?

Within a day or two, as Flying Saucer Review put it, the South African press was enjoying a field day. The question was not whether the men had seen something. The New Zealand Press Association’s correspondent in Johannesburg summed it up: “The national debate concerns the proper protocol for receiving extra-terrestrial visitors.” A police general, quoted as D. A. Bester, said: “I know of no law which forbids you to shoot at an invader from outer space.” The Natal Mercury was appalled that “policemen and a farmer could have tried to shoot out of the sky in broad daylight what might have been a spacecraft from a friendly planet.” Tom Geary, director of the Johannesburg Planetarium, advised that “Shooting them is the last thing one should do. Show you’re friendly and observe them as long as possible.” Uli Resnik, a Johannesburg scientist, said the police had been lucky the object was impervious to bullets: “It was suicidal to shoot at it. If it had exploded it could have destroyed the entire area.” Professor Arthur Bleksley, one of the country’s best-known scientific voices on the subject, asked why visitors would come to Fort Beaufort at all, and East London’s Daily Dispatch replied in a leader that perhaps they liked “a sensible system of roads along which cars actually move without obstruction,” unpolluted air, and “an earth crust that is not honeycombed with mining tunnels.” Van Rensburg’s superiors were less amused. “All they really wanted to know was what Act we had used to decide to fire at the craft and one superior was not amused when I joked, ‘the Stock Theft Act’.” He and Kitching, he said, were severely reprimanded.

Sources: South African Mini-Wave, 1972—Part 2Notice to unidentified flying objects: try to avoid South AfricaLanding ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972Looking BackThe 1972 South African ‘Flap’Mysterious VisitorsFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972

The town comes to watch

The thing, or something like it, would not leave. On the evening of Sunday, July 2, a crowd in Fort Beaufort watched a saucer-shaped light flashing red, blue, green and yellow pass over the town sending down a steady ray, and sent two boys running to the police station to say it seemed to be landing. The next evening the town council adjourned its meeting, and nine carloads of people drove out to Braeside and, The Star reported, “saw an object rise from the undergrowth and head in the direction of Grahamstown.” On July 7 a man at the Savoy Hotel in town saw a UFO hovering over Smit’s farm. Smit had a theory of his own. Shown a photograph of a light over Port Elizabeth, he told the Rand Daily Mail on July 8 that the thing was “definitely manmade,” that it had a base on his farm, and: “I’m going to catch it.” He planned, Clark heard, to use a big net. Kitching remembered the town engineer, Dr. D. Verschoor, interrupting a council meeting a couple of days after the shooting to show the councillors a UFO. On July 9 Dennis Gordon, a Rand Daily Mail reporter and apparently the man who had interviewed Smit standing in his newly planted field of lucerne, or alfalfa, saw a bright light in the sky that he could not explain. In the 1997 retelling, an army delegation from Grahamstown had sealed the farm off for almost two days, and sightseers with picnic baskets watched from the edge of the Fort Fordyce bush next door; a military spokesman in Grahamstown told the same reporter that every officer at the 1972 scene had retired and all the files had been destroyed.

Wide color photograph looking down from high ground over a broad green valley dotted with small homesteads and villages and crossed by dark lines of trees, with rolling hills and a pointed summit rising in the hazy distance under a pale blue sky.
The Tyhume valley from the Hogsback pass in the Amathole Mountains, the hill country east of Fort Beaufort, in 2008. Fort Hare University, where the geologist who examined the prints taught, stands where the valley opens out at Alice. Photo: Lysippos, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Lysippos

Sources: The 1972 South African ‘Flap’South African police fire at UFOFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972Landing ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972

The reservoir bursts

In the early hours of Saturday, July 8, twelve days after the shooting, two explosions were heard and flashing lights were seen over the district. That night, or by daybreak in other accounts, on Braeside, Smit’s reservoir, a brick-and-cement tank some eight meters across holding thousands of gallons, burst apart. Kitching remembered large concrete blocks lying up to twenty meters away; in 1997 the chunks were still scattered in the bush, twenty-five meters off. At the time Van Rensburg thought the collapse could be ordinary wear and tear. The retellings drew it closer to the object. A French UFO magazine, digesting a Belgian one, reported in 1973 that Smit had told the police he saw the UFO minutes before, and wondered whether the reservoir was retaliation for his aggression. Cynthia Hind, the Harare-based investigator, wrote that Smit admitted to her he had heard the object shortly before the reservoir burst, the same whirring, low over his roof, heading for the Fordyce bush. “I didn’t go outside to look. What’s the use, no-one wanted to believe me.” Hind filed it among the cases in which UFOs seemed drawn to water. “Coincidence,” she asked, “or some significance with WATER?” And in August the object came back. Smit’s brother-in-law, R. Rudman, and several farmhands watched a light over the farm for ten minutes; it slowly dimmed, grew smaller and vanished while he went for a camera. De Klerk, who had seen it first, said it was the same thing he had seen in June.

Sources: The 1972 South African ‘Flap’South African police fire at UFOFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972En Afrique du SudUFO Afrinews, no. 5Water and its significance with regard to UFOs: Case No. 27, Fort Beaufort, Cape, South AfricaReport from South Africa and Rhodesia

“How can you shoot a ghost?”

The case spread through the Eastern Cape and beyond. That November, when strange holes appeared in a school tennis court at Rosmead, the police commandant at Middelburg said his men’s reports tallied with the Fort Beaufort object, and Middelburg’s postmaster promised, “We would not shoot at the object like they did at Fort Beaufort.” Charles Bowen of Flying Saucer Review devoted a special supplement to the affair; a decade later he quoted a newspaper commentator who said the men had only been behaving in the traditional South African way of life: “what we don’t understand, we shoot.” Hind gave the case a chapter of her 1982 book UFOs: African Encounters and told a London audience in 1984 that at the time no one had even mentioned outer space, though Van Rensburg remembered Smit’s first words differently. To De Klerk, who saw it first, it was a ghost, “and how can you shoot a ghost?” Hind herself wondered whether it had been a very strange, rather sinister satellite. What puzzled her most was the way it moved: “the fiery object reacted to the voices of the labourers.”

Sources: Report from South Africa and RhodesiaOccupants reported in Cape Province, and UFO damage at Rosmead?Landing ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972The aliens strike backCynthia Hind’s lecture to BUFORA, London, November 3, 1984World Atlas of UFOs

The UFO Bar

Smit kept the rifle. In 1997, at sixty-seven, he told the Sunday Independent’s David Macgregor the story again over red wine in the bar of the Savoy Hotel in Fort Beaufort, which by then he owned and which the locals had renamed the UFO Bar while he was away in France; he let the name stand only after they threatened a boycott. He had been ridiculed for twenty-five years, he said, by professors and scientists among others. “I still don’t believe in aliens and am sceptical they even exist — despite what I saw. It gave me goosebumps.” He had come to think it was a military spy craft that had broken down over his farm. “I wanted to catch the UFO,” he said, “and then we would have had real answers. It was on my farm for a week but I failed. If I was the only one that saw it, I would have been convinced I was either mad or drunk. At least five [of] us saw it that Monday morning and we couldn’t all have been mad.” Van Rensburg, retired to Port Alfred, had turned down American talk shows, as Smit had. “I really don’t know what it was. If a scientist came tomorrow with proof and said it was aliens I would agree,” he said. “If they said it wasn’t, I would also agree. I still think the marks were not made by a human being.”

Sources: Farmer shoots at UFO in 1972

GO TO THE SOURCE

Sources & interviews

Stop Press: South Africa: Farmer and Police fire shots at UFOFlying Saucer Review, vol. 18, no. 4, July–August 1972, pp. 26–27 · reprinting the Sapa report in The Star, Johannesburg, June 27, 1972 · Internet ArchiveMysterious VisitorsBrinsley Le Poer Trench · Souvenir Press, 1973, pp. 152–153 · reprinting “Saucer Trail Probe,” Natal Daily News, June 28, 1972 · Internet ArchiveThe 1972 South African ‘Flap’C. David Oakley-Hill · first published in GEMINI, vol. 1, no. 4, October–December 1972; reprinted in the New BUFORA Journal, no. 7, April 2003, pp. 26–33 · a dated chronology quoting the Sunday Times, Sunday Tribune, Star, Rand Daily Mail and Pretoria News · Internet ArchiveThe South African FlapThe A.P.R.O. Bulletin, September–October 1972, pp. 1, 3–4 · from clippings and a personal contact with Bennie Smit by Frank D. Morton, APRO’s representative for South Africa · Internet ArchiveLanding ved Fort Beaufort: interview med politifolkene, and Den sydafrikanske mini-bølge 1972UFO-NYT, no. 1, January–February 1973, pp. 13–15 · Danish translations of Ivan Clark’s interview with the two policemen and Charles Bowen’s “South African mini-wave, 1972,” part 1, from Flying Saucer Review, vol. 18, no. 5, September–October 1972 · Internet ArchiveSouth African Mini-Wave, 1972—Part 2Charles Bowen · Flying Saucer Review, vol. 18, no. 6, November–December 1972 · with the Daily Dispatch leader of July 7, 1972 · Internet Archive, Flying Saucer Review collection, file 106Notice to unidentified flying objects: try to avoid South AfricaNew Zealand Press Association feature from Johannesburg, a New Zealand paper, September 1972 · UFO Newsclipping Service, nos. 42–43, October–November 1972 · Internet ArchiveUFO Research Newsletter, vol. II, no. 7October–November 1972 · summarizing Malcolm Balfour’s report from the farm in the National Enquirer, October 15, 1972 · Internet ArchiveUFO fik en varm velkomst i SydafrikaAalborg Stiftstidende, July 29, 1972 · reprinted in Ufologen, 1972, no. 1 · Internet ArchiveList of reported UFO sightings in South AfricaWikipedia · its Fort Beaufort entry gives the year as 1971Report from South Africa and RhodesiaThe A.P.R.O. Bulletin, January–February 1973, pp. 4–5, 7 · Frank D. Morton on the August 1972 return of the object to Braeside and the Rosmead case · Internet ArchiveEn Afrique du SudLumières dans la Nuit, no. 124, 1973, pp. 18–19 · a digest of Visiteurs Spatiaux, no. 29 (GESAG, Brussels), from its South African correspondent John de Coster · Internet ArchiveThe aliens strike backCharles Bowen · The Unexplained: Mysteries of Mind, Space & Time, part 66, Orbis, London, p. 1320 · Internet ArchiveCynthia Hind’s lecture to BUFORA, London, November 3, 1984BUFORA Bulletin, no. 18, July 1985 · Internet ArchiveWater and its significance with regard to UFOs: Case No. 27, Fort Beaufort, Cape, South AfricaCynthia Hind · UFO Afrinews, no. 4, March 1991, pp. 17–18 · Internet ArchiveUFO Afrinews, no. 5Cynthia Hind · January 1992, pp. 21–22 · on the reservoir that burst at Braeside · Internet ArchiveWorld Atlas of UFOsJohn Spencer (ed.) · Hamlyn, 1991 · with Cynthia Hind’s essay “UFOs within African culture” · Internet ArchiveLooking BackBob Gribble · MUFON UFO Journal, no. 290, June 1992 · citing The Star (Johannesburg), June 29, 1972, and the Auckland Star, September 18, 1972 · Internet ArchiveFarmer shoots at UFO in 1972David Macgregor · Sunday Independent (Johannesburg), Eastern Cape News, 1997 · as reposted to the UFO UpDates mailing list, November 23, 1997 · Wayback MachineSouth African police fire at UFOThe account of the former Fort Beaufort police sergeant who fired at the object, posted by Brian Vike · The Vike Factor · October 2013Occupants reported in Cape Province, and UFO damage at Rosmead?Flying Saucer Review, vol. 19, no. 1, January–February 1973 · Internet Archive, Flying Saucer Review collectionFort BeaufortWikipedia · on the town’s frontier history and its Martello tower

Spotted an error, or know a better source? Write to hello@uap.fun.

KEEP EXPLORING

Connected files

The Little Men of KellySeventeen years earlier in Kentucky, farm men fired rifles at visitors who seemed untouched by the bullets.Cynthia HindThe investigator who kept the Braeside case alive in African UFO research and heard De Klerk call it a ghost.The Ariel School EncounterHind’s most famous African case, where the witnesses were schoolchildren instead of policemen.The Socorro ArroyoAnother police officer, another daylight object in the scrub, and landing marks measured by the authorities.The Landing at Trans-en-ProvenceA farm, a landing trace and soil samples sent to a national laboratory, with very different results.
THE FORUM

Discuss this case

Compare notes with other readers: witness details, sources, and the parts that still do not add up.

Open the discussion